Is Montserrat the Right Island for You?

For some people, the decision to move to Montserrat happens quickly.

They visit once. They notice the pace. The quiet. The absence of crowds and constant noise. And something inside them eases. Many people who now call the island home look back on that first visit and say the same thing: this is where I want to retire, this is where I can breathe, this feels like home.

That feeling doesn’t come from the island being perfect.
It comes from recognising yourself in the place.

Montserrat doesn’t try to sell itself to you. It shows you what it is. And you either need what she has to offer or you don’t.

An Island You Choose on Purpose

The people who stay in Montserrat long-term usually do so with their eyes open.

They aren’t unaware of the frustrations. They experience the same things everyone does: limited options, delays, infrastructure gaps, small systems that don’t always run smoothly, and the unpredictability that comes with island life shaped by history and natural events.

What sets them apart isn’t denial. It’s acceptance.

They adapt instead of insisting things work the way they’re used to.
They participate instead of just consuming.
They choose to be part of a community, not permanent outsiders passing judgment.

For many who weren’t born here, Montserrat isn’t convenient.
It’s intentional.

Knowing What Montserrat Is and What It Isn’t

Montserrat doesn’t offer endless choice or instant entertainment. It isn’t built around late nights, constant activity, or always having something new to do.

What it offers instead is:

• space
• a slower rhythm
• familiarity
• life on a human scale
• nature that forces you to pause whether you planned to or not

Daily life here revolves around people, not transactions. People know each other. Plans shift based on weather, availability, and reality. Things take time. Patience isn’t optional.

For some, that feels like relief.
For others, it feels suffocating.

Neither reaction is wrong but they lead to very different experiences.

Quiet Doesn’t Mean Nothing Is Happening

Visitors often describe Montserrat as “quiet.” But quiet here doesn’t mean empty.

It means fewer distractions between you and the people around you.
It means conversations that run longer than expected.
It means recognising faces.
It means nights that wind down early and mornings that start with purpose.

The people who tend to do well here value:

• being present more than being busy
• depth more than novelty
• continuity more than constant stimulation

If you need speed, variety, and constant external validation, Montserrat will likely frustrate you.

If you’re comfortable with routine, repetition, and building a life slowly, it can feel like coming up for air.

Community Doesn’t Happen Automatically

Living in Montserrat, whether for a season or for years, takes more than just showing up.

Community is built through listening, consistency, and respect for the island’s history and pace. The things that have shaped Montserrat like loss, displacement, rebuilding, and resilience, aren’t abstract ideas. They affect how people think about change, promises, and trust.

Those who settle well understand that belonging isn’t something you claim.
It’s something you earn quietly.

They show up.
They pay attention.
They adjust.

Choosing Honestly

This isn’t written to discourage anyone from visiting. It’s written to encourage honesty.

Montserrat rewards people who arrive curious rather than demanding, flexible rather than entitled, and willing to meet the island as it actually is, not as it’s sometimes presented elsewhere.

For some, that meeting feels familiar.
For others, it doesn’t.

Both outcomes matter.

Better Questions to Ask Yourself

Before asking what you can do on Montserrat, it’s worth asking yourself:

• How do I really feel about quiet?
• What happens inside me when plans change?
• Do I value community more than convenience?
• Am I willing to learn before I judge?
• Can I be a good guest or a good neighbour here?

If those questions feel uncomfortable, Montserrat may not be the right place for you right now.

If they feel natural, you may already understand more than you think.

Why This Matters

Montserrat doesn’t need everyone to choose it.
It needs the right people to choose it thoughtfully, respectfully, and with care.

That’s where meaningful visits begin.
And sometimes, meaningful lives too.

Part of the Visitor Education Series by Discover Montserrat.

---

Nerissa Golden is the Editor of Discover Montserrat and the founder of Rebel Rock Media Ltd.. Her work focuses on honest, long-form storytelling about Montserrat, culture, and place — beyond headlines, hype, or trends.